UCC at Worlds 2006

From UCC Philosophical Society
Jump to: navigation, search

Tournament[edit]

Adjudication[edit]

Chief Adjudicator
Paul Brady
Deputy Chief Adjudicators
Michael Smith, Fiona Dewar and Erik Eastaugh

Motions[edit]

1 This House Would Grant An Amnesty To All Illegal Immigrants Currently In The United States
2 That This House Believes That The Catholic Church Should Allow The Use Of Condoms In The Fight Against HIV/AIDS In Africa
3 That This House Believes The West Should End Military Cooperation With Pakistan Until It Holds Free Presidential Elections
4 This House Would Prohibit Women Over The Age Of 45 Years From Undergoing Assisted Human Reproduction
5 This House Would Give Japan A Permanent Seat On The United Nations Security Council
6 This House Would Not Allow Intelligent Design To Be Included In The School Science Curriculum
7 This House Would Recognise A Legally Enforceable Right To A Minimum Standard Of Living
8 This House Supports The Creation Of An Independent State For The Iraqi Kurds
9 This House Supports Indigenous Persons Convicted Of A Crime Being Sentenced By Their Community And Not The Courts
Octo Final This House believes that international law should recognise the right of each state to unilaterally undertake armed humanitarian intervention
Quarter Final This House Would permit legislating by citizen initiated referenda
Semi Final This house would prohibit speeches that incite hatred (wording may be incorrect)
Final That this house would abolish all laws prohibiting cruelty to animals

ESL Semi This House would abandon the civilian use of nuclear power.
ESL Final This House Believes that European Governments should pay parents to have children

Contingent[edit]

Teams[edit]

Stephen Coutts & Derek Lande
Derek Doyle & Ross Frenett
Diarmuid Early and Tony Murphy
Paul Flynn & Danny Gleeson
Tiernan Fitzgibbon & Alanna Landers
Luke Harris & Daniel P. McCarthy

Judges[edit]

David McGoldrick
Steven Cull
Will Sherlock
John Gleeson

UCD Worlds 2006[edit]

Total Teams: 324

UCC Teams

Position Team Points Break Speaker 1 Speaker 2
4 UCC Philosoph A 21 Quarters Stephen Coutts Derek Lande
26 UCC Philosoph B 18 Quarters Tony Murphy Diarmuid Early
34 UCC Philosoph C 18 - Derek Doyle Ross Frennett
88 UCC Law A 16 - Daniel P. McCarthy Luke Harris
141 UCC Law B 14 - Tiernan Fitzgibbon Alanna Landers
203 UCC Philosoph D 12 - Paul Flynn Danny Gleeson

UCC Speakers

Position Speaker Total
3 Derek Lande 791
14 Stephen Coutts 762
48 Diarmuid Early 732
74 Tony Murphy 720
103 Derek Doyle 713
132 Ross Frenett 706
236 Tiernan Fitzgibbon 683
240 Daniel P. McCarthy 682
309 Luke Harris 670
336 Danny Gleeson 665
343 Alanna Landers 663
356 Paul Flynn 661